pulling the feels…
pulling the feels…
FLICKFEEL
76
from 93 comments
COMMUNITY
—
nobody yet
YOURS
—
…
FUN
35
how good a time it was
MEANINGFUL
46
how much it moved you
Two separate readings, not parts of the score — the score says how much of it held you, these say what kind of watch it was.
Nobody has rated this on FlickFeel yet. This is public discussion of this title, read into a curve. It is not a rating and it never becomes one.
Read from 93 comments (61 from Reddit, 30 from Metacritic, 2 from TMDB reviews) — 29 of them described how it moves.
➖ steady — Holds one level all the way. Pulled both ways throughout — never simply one thing. Marked above the line: 2 that gave people chills.
Hover the curveDrag across the curve to see what people said at any point.
“The cinematography of the train robbing scene is... I don't have the words for how great it is.”
shed1 · Reddit ↗
“The whole sequence depicting his final days left such a mark on me”
NoDisintegrationz · Reddit ↗
“it drags a little bit”
YeezyWins · Reddit ↗
“that train scene still gives me goosebumps”
Glittering-Ad-6955 · Reddit ↗
“I'm always hooked right from the jump with that narrated intro over the piano track”
TechnicalD-A-W-G · Reddit ↗
“I goddamn loved Jesse James from the moment it started”
Read 28 Aug 2026 · confidence 100% · scored on the same 0-100 scale as a community score · how this works
Published reviews, not felt experience — a different question from the one above, and never mixed into the FlickFeel score.
“The nervy style of this newfangled Western, with its eerie, insinuating score by Nick Cave and Warren Ellis, is so effective that long after Pitt and Affleck have left the screen, emotional disturbance lingers like gun smoke.”
Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly · 100
“A peculiar and destabilizing tone that's far from the standard Hollywood oater, but entirely fitting for two larger-than-life characters fulfilling their roles in history.”
Scott Tobias, The A.V. Club · 100
“Though there is plenty of gunplay, this is a wondrously contemplative and poetic saga that offers a fresh and bewitching take on a timeworn genre.”
Claudia Puig, USA Today · 100
“An extraordinary and visionary study of a legendary murderer’s famous fate, within touching distance of Oscars.”
Ian Nathan, Empire · 100
“Pitt won the Best Actor award at Venice for his Jesse...Yet it's Affleck who impresses most as the wary, skittish Bob.”
Sean Axmaker, Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 91
Scores from Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes, read 28 Aug 2026. Quotes belong to their publications and link to the full reviews.
Grouped by where it was written, because a considered review and a reaction typed an hour after the credits are different things. Every quote links to its source.
“The cinematography of the train robbing scene is... I don't have the words for how great it is.”
shed1▲ 97about 0–15% inread it ↗
“The whole sequence depicting his final days left such a mark on me”
NoDisintegrationz▲ 20about 75–100% inread it ↗
“it drags a little bit”
YeezyWins▲ 16about 0–100% inread it ↗
“that train scene still gives me goosebumps”
Glittering-Ad-6955▲ 13about 60–70% inread it ↗
“the film is slow, but very impactful especially during the payoff moments.”
MatePolczabout 75–100% inread it ↗
“Introspective and slow paced western”
NickTheCritickabout 0–100% inread it ↗
“the final moments of the film and spine-tingling score will stay with you long after the credits roll”
fonzeaabout 75–100% inread it ↗
“Andrew Dominik is in his A game where he bring out his big guns sooner than expected and hits hard and fast which later turns out to be a bad influence in it”
amheretojudgeabout 0–15% inread it ↗
“The final 25 minutes detail the Ford brothers’ lives over the course of the next decade after James' execution on April 3, 1882.”
Wuchakabout 75–100% inread it ↗
“Perfection. I think I will just come right out and say it from the off, this is a masterpiece, a truly spell binding, mesmerising tour de force that seeps class from every pore. I have often found myself cringing and turning my back on those who use in film debate the tired old defence of "it's not for everyone", but here I find I have no choice because this picture is purely for those enamoured with poetic beauty and precision film making at its highest. Those in search of an all action gun ”
John Chardread it ↗
no tags yet — rate this flick to drop some vibes ✨