pulling the feelsβ¦
pulling the feelsβ¦
FLICKFEEL
54
from 280 comments
COMMUNITY
β
nobody yet
YOURS
β
β¦
FUN
9
how good a time it was
MEANINGFUL
73
how much it moved you
Two separate readings, not parts of the score β the score says how much of it held you, these say what kind of watch it was.
Nobody has rated this on FlickFeel yet. This is public discussion of this title, read into a curve. It is not a rating and it never becomes one.
Read from 280 comments (230 from Reddit, 44 from Metacritic, 6 from TMDB reviews) β 63 of them described how it moves.
β steady β Holds one level all the way. Pulled both ways throughout β never simply one thing. Very little of it ever resolves. Marked above the line: 1 moment that made people jump, 1 that landed as a blow, 2 that gave people chills, 1 that got a real laugh.
Hover the curveDrag across the curve to see what people said at any point.
βWhen the movie is good, it's good. Like all of Dain's scenes, the Dwarven Shield Wall, Thorin's madness, and the discipline of the Elven Army.β
FedaykinII Β· Reddit β
βBut when it's bad, one cannot fathom how absolutely terrible this adaptation is. The incomprehensible forced love story, the utter lack of any closure for any character that isn't Bilbo, the evil monologue of Smaug, the incoherence of the battle sequence, the misplaced awkward references to the LOTR story, and the horrendous CGI.β
FedaykinII Β· Reddit β
βI don't see any reasons why they ended Desolation of Smaug on a cliffhanger other than to blue-ball the audience into buying tickets for this movie. It felt like the climax of the last movie, not the intro to this one.β
rod_munch Β· Reddit β
βThe buildup to the battle was great.β
rod_munch Β· Reddit β
βToo bad the actual battle was boring.β
rod_munch Β· Reddit β
βall the waiting around in the first two moviesβ
Read 26 Aug 2026 Β· confidence 100% Β· scored on the same 0-100 scale as a community score Β· how this works
Published reviews, not felt experience β a different question from the one above, and never mixed into the FlickFeel score.
βIf The Hobbit doesn't equal the achievement of Jackson's earlier Middle-earth movies -- and, honestly, what could? -- it is still, in sum, a thrilling effort.β
Richard Corliss, Time Β· 90
βThe best film of The Hobbit's three, this final installment is closer in quality to "The Lord of the Rings" than to its immediate predecessors.β
James Berardinelli, ReelViews Β· 88
βFighting β presented with Jacksonβs usual double helpings of visual splendor, emotional oomph and low-key comedy β is what Battle of the Five Armies is all about.β
Bruce Ingram, Chicago Sun-Times Β· 88
βBy focusing on a few key emotional arcs instead of making it about every shot being the BIGGEST THING OF ALL TIME, Jackson gives the battle a sense of urgency that builds and ebbs, builds and ebbs.β
Drew McWeeny, Hitfix Β· 83
βThe final stretch of The Battle of the Five Armies possesses a warm, amiable, sometimes rueful mood that proves ingratiating and manages to magnify the good and minimize the bad of the trilogy.β
Todd McCarthy, The Hollywood Reporter Β· 80
Scores from Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes, read 24 Aug 2026. Quotes belong to their publications and link to the full reviews.
Grouped by where it was written, because a considered review and a reaction typed an hour after the credits are different things. Every quote links to its source.
βWhen the movie is good, it's good. Like all of Dain's scenes, the Dwarven Shield Wall, Thorin's madness, and the discipline of the Elven Army.β
FedaykinIIβ² 1,052about 0β100% inread it β
βBut when it's bad, one cannot fathom how absolutely terrible this adaptation is. The incomprehensible forced love story, the utter lack of any closure for any character that isn't Bilbo, the evil monologue of Smaug, the incoherence of the battle sequence, the misplaced awkward references to the LOTR story, and the horrendous CGI.β
FedaykinIIβ² 1,052about 0β100% inread it β
βI don't see any reasons why they ended Desolation of Smaug on a cliffhanger other than to blue-ball the audience into buying tickets for this movie. It felt like the climax of the last movie, not the intro to this one.β
rod_munchβ² 795about 0β15% inread it β
βThe buildup to the battle was great.β
rod_munchβ² 795about 0β33% inread it β
no tags yet β rate this flick to drop some vibes β¨